It may come as a surprise that Maplewood has never designated a local historic district within its borders as many residents move there precisely because of the old homes. However, that could change.
Last month, the Historic Preservation Commission took a significant step toward designating a historic district along Ridgewood Road, voting to pursue a nomination.
“Few areas of Maplewood illustrate such a long period of the township’s development in one place,” said Daniel Wright, chair of the Historic Preservation Commission. “It’s one of the first parts of town you learn about when you look into the history of Maplewood.”
Wright noted that the vote is not tantamount to a designation, it only authorizes the commission to oversee a more detailed nomination report. “It’s not a final determination,” Wright said. “That’s a decision that the Township Committee would make after several additional steps in the process.”
Once the new nomination report is completed, the commission will vote to send the nomination to the Township Committee, before it is referred to the Planning Board, returning back to the Township Committee, who will vote on an ordinance creating the historic district.
“The nomination proposal is really just the first step,” said Steven Smolyn, an architectural historian whose firm Architectural Heritage Consultants was hired as a consultant to the HPC. “And based on the information to date, which is quite a bit, I believe there is sufficient evidence of historic and architectural significance in this area to warrant a more detailed evaluation.”
Valerie Hufnagel, a Ridgewood Road resident and board president of the Hoboken Historical Museum, said she hopes the designation moves forward to ward off the demolition of more historic homes.
“One of the worst things that I’m seeing in this town, which I love dearly, is the traditions and putting up these ugly, ugly homes that will far apart,” she said. “You can’t beat an old home.”
Douglas Stevenson said the recent demolition of a 19th-century barn at 641 Ridgewood Road near his home was part of the reason he supports designating the historic district as it will give the community more input on what is built on that property.
“The barn’s been torn down. It’s been subdivided. Who knows what’s going up next?” he said. “I live on Ridgewood Road and I think it’s incredibly important to preserve the historical nature of the entire town.”
However, critics of the nomination objected to the potential rise in cost to make exterior repairs, as their choice in materials would be restricted in some cases. Others claimed that there was insufficient outreach to homeowners in the proposed boundaries of the historic district. There were two community meetings — the last one was in June — to discuss the designation.
One Ridgewood Road resident said that protecting old homes from demolition or alteration shouldn’t be a priority and opposed “additional restrictions.”
“I just find this whole fetishization of old homes this really weird thing that people tend to do,” said Fabian McNally. “I bought a house so that I could do what I want with that house.”
The township attorney, Jennifer Credidio, said the list of improvements or alterations to a person’s home that require the commission’s review can be Section 271-80 of Maplewood’s zoning laws.
“Anyone who is going to be impacted by a future designation, if that is to come to pass, I would encourage you to review that section of the code,” Credidio said.
The proposed historic district contains 137 homes, schools, and churches along Ridgewood Road from Berkeley Road to Cedar Lane and on some of the side streets. However, the boundaries of historic districts often change as the process moves to the finish line. The neighborhood already contains individually listed landmarks, including the Durand-Hedden House, a community center. That home, built in 1790, and others like the Timothy Ball, which dates back to 1743, are there because of the existence of an old Lenape road.
Ridgewood Road is not just one of the oldest places in Maplewood, but it tells an important story about the founding of the nation and what preceded it, according to Gail Safian, board president of the Durand-Hedden House.
“We just don’t want to lose the touchstones of history when so much of the country is being bulldozed to make developments and townhouses,” Safian said. “It’s a very appealing place and the idea of making it a historic district is to preserve the reason that people moved to Maplewood in the first place.”
Watch the Historic Preservation Commission meeting on Oct. 31, 2027.



